Join day by day information updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or observe us on Google Information!
An electrical arc furnace is sort of a big, high-tech kitchen equipment for melting metallic. Think about an enormous, strong pot the place you throw in scrap metallic, like previous vehicles or damaged home equipment. As a substitute of utilizing fuel or coal to warmth issues up, this “pot” makes use of highly effective electrical arcs — consider them as supercharged lightning bolts. These arcs create intense warmth, sufficient to soften the scrap metallic into liquid type.
Enter limestone, the ever-present smooth, shallowly buried stays of lengthy vanished seabeds. In an electrical arc furnace (EAF), limestone is a multi-purpose helper. When scrap metallic melts down, it usually brings alongside undesirable friends like sulfur and phosphorus. Limestone jumps in to bond with these impurities, forming a separate layer referred to as slag that floats to the highest, making it straightforward to skim off and discard. This slag additionally acts like a protecting blanket, shielding the molten metallic from air and stopping oxidation. Plus, limestone helps handle the furnace’s temperature, ensuring issues don’t get too scorching or too chilly. About 50 kilograms of limestone are used per ton of metal.
Sadly, simply as in a limestone kiln on a cement plant, this creates a bunch of carbon dioxide, about 22 kilograms per ton of metal. Curiously for me, the carbon within the limestone isn’t used for the carbon content material of the ensuing metal. New metal constituted of iron has carbon from quite a lot of sources added, however the scrap metal utilized in EAFs already has carbon. If the carbon content material must be adjusted, completely different components that run the gamut from coal to plant-derived substances are combined in, however the carbon within the limestone simply goes up the chimney.
A ton of metal requires 400 to 500 kWh of electrical energy. With the US grid’s common carbon depth per kWh, a ton of metal might need a carbon debt of about 0.2 tons of carbon dioxide per ton of metal from the electrical energy necessities. Clearly with a low-carbon grid, that will plummet to maybe 0.02 tons of carbon dioxide. Many US EAF crops use 10% to twenty% pure fuel for added course of warmth as a result of it’s low cost, which provides roughly 0.02 tons of carbon dioxide to the combination. In a future inexperienced grid, pure fuel gained’t be used. Meaning sooner or later, EAF metal’s carbon dioxide emissions will really be dominated by course of emissions from limestone.
The slag is primarily made up of calcium oxide from the limestone, silicon dioxide from impurities, iron oxide from extra iron, and bits of aluminum oxide and magnesium oxide. The sharp eyes who’ve been wading knee deep by means of the articles I’m forsaking this week of cement can have noticed the calcium oxide, silicon dioxide, and aluminum oxide and questioned why they sounded so acquainted, until they’re cement nerds, during which case they’re nicely down the trail I’m main you alongside in the meanwhile.
The primary substances in Portland cement are calcium from limestone, iron oxide, silica from sand, and alumina from clay. That ought to make clear why loads of cement nerds are EAF slag and EAF furnaces with appreciative eyes. This popped for me with the set off for my private cement week, information of a Cambridge UK tutorial group’s use of EAF furnaces to in some way recycle concrete. It’s taken me some time to get again to them, however in the present day is the day. What precisely are they doing?
The Cambridge group operates underneath the title “Cambridge Electric Cement.” This mission is a part of the broader analysis initiatives on the College of Cambridge and entails collaboration with varied trade and tutorial companions. The group contains researchers like Dr. Cyrille Dunant, Professor Julian Allwood, and Dr. Philippa Horton, who’ve been instrumental in creating and scaling this expertise.
Not like different organizations that are utilizing the slag instantly, successfully letting the EAF furnace be the limestone kiln, the Cambridge group are reducing limestone out of the equation. As famous, the carbon and additional oxygen within the limestone that flip into carbon dioxide are surplus to necessities, and all the stuff that cement wants is within the cement. Concrete is closely recycled already, crushed to extract the metal reinforcing wire mesh or rebar, and crushed into combination for brand new concrete and building fill to exchange new gravel.
The Cambridge group inserts one other couple of steps on this course of. They use mechanical means to separate the mixture from the cement, then crush the cement right into a paste, which they course of to take away impurities like natural materials, metallic fragments, plastic, and water. The ensuing powder has all of the substances of cement, however not put collectively the best manner.
They combine this powder with the melted metal as a substitute of limestone. When the slag varieties and is cooled off, it’s successfully simply chunks of activated cement that may be floor like clinker out of a clinker kiln. No limestone with its surplus-to-requirements carbon, so no extra course of carbon dioxide. This course of, the place it could possibly be used, would remove course of limestone emissions from EAF metal, bringing its carbon debt all the way down to a extra manageable 0.02 tons of carbon dioxide per ton of metal. By comparability, new metal from new iron within the conventional coal-heavy course of have 2 to three tons of carbon dioxide per ton of metal — 100 to 150 occasions extra.
The ensuing cement could be very near Portland cement, nevertheless, it’s not Portland cement precisely, notably being increased in iron oxide. As famous within the evaluation of limestone calcined clay cement (LC3), Portland cement, its traits, and infrequently exact compositions are written into laws and constructing codes in any respect ranges of presidency. Gaining approval for this EAF slag cement is way from trivial. It’s a really good technical hack that recycles cement and displaces limestone, however an enormous change administration course of is required if it have been for use for structural parts in constructing and infrastructure. That’s really an enormous if, and extra on that later.
Additional, whereas we scrap loads of concrete in the present day, the Cambridge group’s math varies from mine. They assume that they might scale this course of as much as a billion tons a 12 months, however as I labored out when wanting on the Elegant Techniques electrochemistry strategy to doing precisely what the Cambridge group is doing, I might solely discover about two billion tons of concrete waste yearly, representing about 5% of a single 12 months’s use of concrete. It is sensible that we’re constructing much more than we’re demolishing. Solely 10% to fifteen% of that’s Portland cement. Assuming 10% is recovered, that’s solely 200 million tons of potential useful resource.
There’s one other problem. Whereas in my projection of iron and metal by means of 2100, we’ll be scrapping metal much more for brand new metal wants, simply because the USA does in the present day, it’s nonetheless solely going to be about 1.7 billion tons made in EAF amenities. Exterior references recommend they’re nonetheless utilizing about 50 kilograms of recycled cement as flux per ton of metal, the identical quantity as when limestone is used, which appears a bit odd, however I’ll go along with it. If all EAF amenities used recycled cement as flux, that’s solely 85 million tons of recycled cement per 12 months.
To be clear, that will displace 85 million tons of carbon dioxide from cement manufacturing and one other 37 million tons from EAF metal manufacturing, round 120 million tons or 0.3% of complete world emissions of carbon dioxide. That’s 2% of cement manufacturing emissions. That’s fairly good, but it surely’s an order of magnitude off of what the Cambridge group is claiming. It’s unclear how they labored up these numbers.
As I famous, EAF slag is used for lots of stuff in the present day as nicely, and there are opponents for its use, like Elegant Techniques. That agency’s course of isn’t fairly as virtuous as displacing limestone completely, however it may be used towards limestone, cement, and EAF slag, so just like the comparability to Brimstone, it seems inherently extra versatile. Nonetheless no thought of whether or not it may be severely scaled, after all, but it surely does appear to be a really promising, low-heat, electrochemistry hack to attain new lime for cement with none regulatory points about Portland cement.
Carbicrete makes use of metal slag from EAFs as a key ingredient. They combine this slag with common concrete substances after which inject carbon dioxide into the combination in a sealed chamber. The carbon dioxide reacts with the metal slag to type a strong binding materials that holds the concrete collectively. This not solely makes use of up CO2 that will in any other case be within the environment, but additionally skips the entire limestone-heating step, which is an enormous supply of emissions in common cement manufacturing. They create molded concrete blocks and different precast parts with this course of.
About 20% to 25% of all concrete is used for precast parts, so this can be a huge wedge. And as a bonus, whereas Portland cement is laid out in regulatory codes for structural parts of buildings, it usually isn’t specified for precast parts. That signifies that this course of and the Cambridge group’s can be utilized for precast parts, and additional the volumes will properly match into the provision chain for that house. It’s potential that some mixture of the Carbicrete course of and the Cambridge course of would finest work collectively, with recycling of cement displacing limestone and the Carbicrete course of being utilized on the end result. Exhausting to say, but it surely’s good that there are a number of choices.
The DRI-EOS mission, coordinated by the FEhS Institute, brings collectively a number of companions, together with Salzgitter Mannesmann Forschung GmbH, the Federal Institute for Supplies Analysis and Testing (BAM), Friedrich Rohstoffe GmbH, Holcim Deutschland GmbH, and LOI Thermprocess GmbH. The mission is engaged on how finest to make use of EAF slag for cement as nicely. Their hack seems to be taking part in with the chemistry of inputs to the EAF course of to regulate the slag chemistry to be extra aligned with cement, then quickly cooling the slag to make one thing extra like clinker, in order that it may be floor, combined, and bagged instantly. Nonetheless limestone, it seems, however a cleaner course of in different methods.
Metal big ArcelorMittal is doing one thing with this as nicely, however its distinctive strategy to the query just isn’t public, or at the very least I couldn’t discover it. As one of many world’s bigger producers of waste from metal, nevertheless, it’s in its curiosity to make that waste stream as invaluable as potential. Presently loads of slag finally ends up underneath railway tracks as ballast, which in all probability isn’t one thing that makes the corporate some huge cash.
Cement big Halcim has been utilizing EAF slag for years in its Envirocore Sequence, with about 41 million tons of different industries’ waste included in its merchandise as of 2018. As famous firstly of this piece, cement nerds have been EAF slag for a very long time.
World built-in chemical plant big BASF is utilizing EAF slag as nicely. It doesn’t manufacture cement, but it surely does manufacture the admixtures that get combined with cement, water, sand, and combination to make concrete. Clearly the top recreation for EAF slag cement startups is to have a Halcim, ArcelorMittal, or BASF purchase them, work out their golden handcuff interval and retire to a cement-free seashore within the Bahamas. I assume the biggies have chapter and verse on all the completely different startups and analysis initiatives underneath manner, and every have their very own scoring system for potential acquisition.
I additionally assume that at the very least some EAF plant operators are getting aggravated by all the cement nerds calling them on a regular basis. Lots of cement decarbonization pathways run by means of EAF crops, so loads of cement mud will get combined in with the metal already.
